# Incident Report: 37,000 SOL in Losses — A Call for Investigation and Action

**URL:** <https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853>\
**Category:** Uncategorized\
**Created:** [May 9, 2025, 12:14pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853 "2025-05-09T12:14:04Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 15\
**Page:** 2

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 12, 2025, 6:10pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/23 "2025-05-12T18:10:37Z")

</div>

Well, since Marinade has decided to stay silent and not comment on the situation, even after the people from the Top 10 themselves revealed the entire scheme of receiving free stake, we will continue to bring attention to the issue that has not been solved with the new fix. Validators are not receiving any penalties and continue to receive stake from Marinade, even with bids lower than 0.01 SOL.

In epoch 785, the MIN\_effective\_BID was 0.078 SOL. In this epoch, Marinade missed at least **199.72 SOL**.

As of **epoch 785** , there are **92 validators** receiving stake from Marinade, while their bid is less than 0.01 SOL. Two validators have been penalized. One was completely stripped of their bond — a total of **302.987 SOL** was deducted as a penalty ( **55d5XyCu3Ap1yLHHJd6ChBT3pgP4HE6MPmJrU7TbAwYw** ), and the second lost only **44.971 SOL** , but still has a remaining bond of **46.932 SOL** ( **2wUhcnViyzstvWmk7NAboKtjbFbqJPo4BvFBV37dacLc** ), which will likely be enough for one more epoch.

The **total stake** , either fully or partially unpaid by validators for **epoch 785** , is **2,590,198.891 SOL** (this figure already excludes the two penalized validators mentioned above).

Additionally, it’s worth noting that **5 validators have set their MEV commission to 100%** , meaning that **stakers are not receiving any MEV income** from these validators. The total stake for these validators is **410,000 SOL**.

| № | Vote Account | Marinade Activated Stake (SOL) | Bid Cpmpe | Inflation Commission | MEV Commission | Stake Priority | Unstake Priority |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | 55d5XyCu3Ap1yLHHJd6ChBT3pgP4HE6MPmJrU7TbAwYw | 362335,1618 | 0.0001 | 0.07 | 0.1 | 288 | 142 |
| 2 | Cue647T8jgwpRSDUb8ttTYx7NiEfJCRZNiiw1qmchXsG | 337320,6683 | 0.0 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 283 | 134 |
| 3 | 4m1PbxzwLdUnEwog3T9UKxgjktgriHgE1CfAhMqDw7Xx | 312484,9489 | 0.0 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 283 | 135 |
| 4 | ErJmwESSzVrDuDJcN5L47XnM84JWDwTi6bDMWkrXqHSV | 197150,4497 | 0.0 | 0.05 | 1.0 | 305 | 146 |
| 5 | 9f7dqiYNBZbgPesAnLeWnKCtxYHSfMg5x1EMZCJwVwG7 | 138792,4167 | 1,00E-09 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 248 | 102 |
| 6 | 4WGMxMKhjKz9TSmn6NA52AVipeE3zZNPBhQuBghZBvqU | 131530,4489 | 0.0 | 0.07 | 1.0 | 308 | 61 |
| 7 | Simpj3KyRQmpRkXuBvCQFS7DBBG6vqw93SkZb9UD1hp | 129468,8123 | 1,00E-07 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 280 | 131 |
| 8 | GMiBDMmwFRZfxVuHt3bXe6ZF7mGUBGWKXHLfY97NwQ72 | 109470,2366 | 0.007 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 264 | 120 |
| 9 | 21wUViiyG1g47VZ39ZZsSkFX9nu6bkyfy6jryHGD2TUB | 107036,269 | 1,00E-09 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 248 | 103 |
| 10 | EARTHZeTM64X3UMYf5rcWonQkTCn3uifEwutBx6e656K | 82464,06124 | 0.0 | 0.07 | 0.1 | 290 | 143 |
| 11 | StepeLdhJ2znRjHcZdjwMWsC4nTRURNKQY8Nca82LJp | 80867,89661 | 0.0 | 0.07 | 1.0 | 308 | 148 |
| 12 | 5akpkYincAbsTBXVbf2GDCg4KatMnc8BKkXZCh7MWGPK | 79391,67014 | 8,00E-05 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 241 | 98 |
| 13 | 3teZKwABvB99bxZc5q8yVWJt5mbhxgUAx4teMdUbzgN4 | 77283,1441 | 0.001 | 0.0 | 0.0999 | 236 | 94 |
| 14 | 2w4dcnbJDcGrAh4CFAYYpAaEJiUB2q1rFMGByBuB5Cqz | 75867,35702 | 0.001 | 0.0 | 0.08 | 229 | 89 |
| 15 | HvuXZAhAqSekCFueQ92DqxhuFvdBRrWeyA6uea6ZaS8q | 74775,45883 | 0.001 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 237 | 95 |
| 16 | 2wUhcnViyzstvWmk7NAboKtjbFbqJPo4BvFBV37dacLc | 61003,44797 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 217 | 85 |
| 17 | 3ZUQekqiZoybB57y49eqtvSaoonqDwuNbeqEGwN88JkQ | 55635,66671 | 1,00E-09 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 216 | 81 |
| 18 | Hx4UJCvf8amGeuW9fPFfTckRoznDHxPSYiU9HuUSZKLT | 53320,58077 | 0.0 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 283 | 137 |
| 19 | 8ztfVJM7Yf7CMXqTGMGBkXmTkGCiJTgVfh1CYDZZND5b | 52900,25462 | 0.0 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 283 | 139 |
| 20 | EJHf5N9is5spAF5Kz384tTvTV3CwTka6qzUoZrYm53SV | 51722,44536 | 1,00E-09 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 282 | 133 |
| 21 | 3tjGkvUsNEk8UBUQECCTpeAoo6NovHvEG44MZDPCcZko | 48487,93843 | 0.005 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 268 | 123 |
| 22 | 3CnKZPQn92W8WXG7KTVaFQRk8LJJ3KZbrVVF4ngUxqkg | 46126,73379 | 0.001 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 237 | 97 |
| 23 | Fbnesg4kSDDoFbjaSiDQJ3GXHHAnNb1CJCgLQp4dxj4C | 38185,19548 | 0.001 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 237 | 96 |
| 24 | DsT3eKbWAaX9wVZQYBsbkDwpFA9NTDtXfsYc9wXUEWpn | 34036,04015 | 8,00E-07 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 246 | 101 |
| 25 | BHuk6wv9pskvSuMxzAFksmFNxEWZDHDsYWSwvTKcCnhx | 30288,36569 | 0.004 | 0.0 | 0.07 | 220 | 87 |
| 26 | HMLfMHdETcGSqPGAr38rSiwewsSZvLPMMPALc5pggtiW | 27905,4588 | 0.002 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 272 | 127 |
| 27 | 8hPk5CbKDoM7dN9LssTdVkFhDykeq7A8CZurA5AQSFJH | 23910,92528 | | 0.05 | 0.05 | 271 | 0 |
| 28 | Anv7J9kMdJWr1aU6rQvQyd24zBp5GscP8NeDpRqGKz8e | 23505,10654 | 8,00E-07 | 0.07 | 0.1 | 289 | 62 |
| 29 | 323d4ZiSqS1PwGwpJwD88jNPaGqkm7YYW2tJt2T8iFzo | 21707,64198 | 1,00E-05 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 244 | 100 |
| 30 | CatzoSMUkTRidT5DwBxAC2pEtnwMBTpkCepHkFgZDiqb | 20478,89426 | | 0.0 | 0.0 | 217 | 0 |
| 31 | 8HKqT579dAjdTy86zKUs8kAaGDHXY11wDC3ohGCkLSQH | 17185,46122 | 0.0085 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 261 | 119 |
| 32 | sBcuGeMJCRkdtMNgskLTX7MePb4CzCqZuyMKDrcPP8v | 16706,19795 | 8,00E-07 | 0.07 | 0.1 | 289 | 64 |
| 33 | 8FPz3JG4E3HVXxGbPZVibarva4AGXSZWx3qKLUS5uFtN | 12358,63082 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 249 | 109 |
| 34 | GA2t11gJcmuZ4y7pShTzgYDkxVaJaVQJqkVUqojhPPsT | 10345,50666 | 4,00E-09 | 0.04 | 0.1 | 269 | 124 |
| 35 | DTwEEF6VSrmTBYkDcj3BKAc52qhvP8CEQUEAMMT1cG3 | 10047,01665 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 249 | 108 |
| 36 | GB44NXtM7zGm6QnzQjzHZcRKSswkJbox8aJsKiXGbFJr | 9317,851004 | 0.0 | 0.01 | 0.08 | 253 | 112 |
| 37 | J1to3PQfXidUUhprQWgdKkQAMWPJAEqSJ7amkBDE9qhF | 8137,735347 | | 0.0 | 0.08 | 234 | 0 |
| 38 | juicQdAnksqZ5Yb8NQwCLjLWhykvXGktxnQCDvMe6Nx | 6878,668786 | 0.0 | 0.04 | 0.08 | 267 | 121 |
| 39 | H7fXvnLCKtZqJBTipxeseabGfAZUdHJ9XuP6hCKrbvUb | 6012,574225 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.08 | 234 | 93 |
| 40 | EARNynHRWg6GfyJCmrrizcZxARB3HVzcaasvNa8kBS72 | 3736,763268 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 249 | 104 |
| 41 | WENuuMXGi8adKogNbQj33Vxgia9oA2erkWAPF4szWN1 | 3511,816524 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 217 | 86 |
| 42 | DriFTm3wM9ugxhCA1K3wVQMSdC4Dv4LNmyZMmZiuHRpp | 3357,078095 | | 0.0 | 0.0 | 217 | 0 |
| 43 | BeSov1og3sEYyH9JY3ap7QcQDvVX8f4sugfNPf9YLkcV | 2321,337787 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 249 | 106 |
| 44 | EpicsoqLdDP8qRn3wQRKTSKAXbjK9dUgFfNPRQS77MQD | 2007,747526 | | 0.0 | 0.0 | 217 | 0 |
| 45 | FyrSH4VeQidMVPQ9AE2szAbP5xBZBprRG3z1QMMLNi5X | 1631,074478 | 1,00E-06 | 0.0 | 0.1 | 245 | 51 |
| 46 | 3N7s9zXMZ4QqvHQR15t5GNHyqc89KduzMP7423eWiD5g | 1599,176914 | | 0.08 | 0.1 | 294 | 0 |
| 47 | vahVByZszdHguLa7U7GLz8UdUFN85mcwdkefiqVjtGt | 1577,373274 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.099 | 243 | 99 |
| 48 | FnAPJkzf19s87sm24Qhv6bHZMZvZ43gjNUBRgjwXpD4v | 1537,834954 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.08 | 234 | 91 |
| 49 | ErvMUdtMC7AX55zKdYSyy4DnWNCrTsWn5GwprSG7ocnx | 1309,747813 | 0.0 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 283 | 141 |
| 50 | 9kkP5sRnyHD3qkyHykyWwbP9pQQcTWnzLPHtDcRxaE16 | 1110,513148 | 1,00E-05 | 0.05 | 0.1 | 278 | 0 |
| 51 | he1iusunGwqrNtafDtLdhsUQDFvo13z9sUa36PauBtk | 1049,927491 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 0.0 | 217 | 46 |

I did not publish the remaining validators because their stake from Marinade in epoch 785 is less than 1000 SOL (and they also do not pay for it, or pay partially). 1000 SOL of free stake — is it really that much in the context of a 37,000 SOL loss? I’m right to assume this, aren’t I?

Also, I would like to address those validators who say something like: “Oh, I didn’t know I was doing something wrong. Yes, I took advantage of the vulnerability, but it’s not my problem, it’s Marinade’s fault.”

**Dear validators** , if you find a vulnerability in a banking system and exploit it, you’ll likely face real criminal charges in your country. But you probably won’t exploit that vulnerability because you understand the consequences.  
However, vulnerabilities in Marinade can be exploited without any fear of consequences, right? Of course, no one will punish you. **This is exactly what Marinade demonstrates with its behavior and by ignoring this thread.**

**Well, no worries, we will continue to raise awareness of the scale of the issue to the Solana Foundation.**

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![repe](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/repe/32/106_2.png) [@repe](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/repe)\
**Post date:** [May 12, 2025, 7:22pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/24 "2025-05-12T19:22:54Z")

</div>

I want to start with a necessary clarification: Marinade only reports **realized APY** — meaning actual returns earned by users, not projections or theoretical estimates based on validator bids.

Thanks to everyone who’s contributed to this thread. I want to clarify a few things and correct some misleading claims that have gained traction.

The 37,000 SOL figure circulated refers to estimated missed rewards, not actual loss. No user funds were ever at risk, and no SOL was “siphoned” from stakers. Marinade reports only the realized performance. The APY shown on the app and website reflects actual mSOL appreciation — not theoretical validator bids or ideal conditions.

A small number of validators indeed reduced their bids after winning stake in the auction. That wasn’t the behavior Marinade intended to reward. A fix for that is already live: the **bid reduction penalty** now punishes this exact pattern by slashing rewards when validators try to undercut their original bid. So far, more than **500 SOL** has been redistributed to stakers through this mechanism.

Documentation is available here: [Delegation Strategy v2 | Marinade.Finance](https://docs.marinade.finance/marinade-protocol/system-overview/delegation-strategy-v2#bid-reduction-penalty)

Some context around the scale: during the same 126-epoch window, Marinade stakers earned roughly:

- 93,000 SOL from validator bids
- 420,000 SOL in inflation rewards
- 80,000 SOL in MEV
- 2,000 SOL in PSR penalties
- **~595,000 SOL total**

The inefficiency identified accounts for around 6 percent of that—not zero, but not what the headlines make it out to be either.

There’s also been discussion around how **unstake priority** was implemented in the auction logic. Based on internal analysis and community input, including [GitHub issue #24](https://github.com/marinade-finance/ds-sam/issues/24), it appeared that the system may unintentionally deprioritize unstaking from low-paying validators.

While the GitHub issue proposed a potential fix, Marinade’s engineering team evaluated it and determined it would not fully resolve it. Instead, the team has decided to address the problem holistically as part of a broader update to the priority system. This is under active development.

The auction was never designed to be perfect from day one. Like any living mechanism, it evolves with new data and behavior patterns. What matters is that the protocol can adapt, which has happened here. This wasn’t about negligence or allowing abuse. It was about identifying where a small set of actors were pushing past the boundaries of what the system anticipated, and tightening those boundaries accordingly.

There’s also a broader point getting lost in the narrative: MEV has existed on Solana long before SAM. Validators have been participating in MEV across the network for years. Marinade didn’t introduce that — it introduced a way to redirect some of that value to stakers. Users could share in MEV for the first time through open bidding, validator competition, and transparent rewards.

That’s not an exploit. That’s alignment.

Marinade also introduced mechanisms like **Protected Staking Rewards** , which require validators to post a bond that can be used to compensate users in the event of reward underperformance. This is not a free market where validators can disappear after getting stake. There are penalties, obligations, and incentives structured around protecting users.

There are ways SAM can improve — and it will. But the takeaway here isn’t that the system failed. It’s working as intended. Abusive behavior was identified, quantified, and addressed through a protocol-level change. No staker was harmed. All APY was based on actual returns. And the validator auction is already stronger than it was a month ago.

Looking ahead, Marinade is focused on improving the stability of the validator set and reducing unnecessary stake rebalances. This will help increase APY for stakers and ensure more stake flows for honest validators.

Specifically, the team is:

- Designing a **validator reputation system** to reward consistently reliable operators
- Exploring **auction improvements** to allow honest validators to earn more
- Continuing to evaluate **priority logic** , following the recent fix via the **BidTooLow penalty**

Each of these changes is approached systematically, with a deep understanding of how they impact the broader rebalancing process. That’s the only way to design a complex system that serves users, maintains decentralization, and adapts to validator behavior over time.

Marinade will continue publishing data, evolving the system, and enforcing fairness through code. That’s the promise — and it’s being delivered.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 12, 2025, 7:49pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/25 "2025-05-12T19:49:02Z")

</div>

Hello Repe,

I truly appreciate that you took the time to post an official response from the Marinade team in this thread. It’s good to see some movement — and the introduction of the `BidTooLow` penalty mechanism is definitely a step in the right direction.

That said, I’d encourage you to scroll back and take another look at the validators I mentioned earlier. Some of them **aren’t being penalized at all** under your new logic — despite having **tiny or even zero bids** and still continuing to receive delegation.  
So yes, you may have patched one bug… but it seems **another one is still alive and well**. Please take a serious look.

If I may ask a straightforward question:

Why did this bug go unpatched for **120 epochs**?

Let’s assume, for the sake of argument, that your team only recently became aware of the issue. But I know for a fact that **multiple validators reached out months ago** — some of whom underpaid Marinade by **up to 1,000 SOL** — and even created GitHub issues describing the problem in detail.

So what happened?

- Was the bug reported internally but never escalated to you?
- Or did the team knowingly decide not to fix it?

Honestly, I’m struggling to understand how a protocol that manages **over 9 million SOL in TVL** could let a flaw like this persist for so long. Whether it’s a communication breakdown or a product decision — neither looks great from the outside.

I hope you can clarify.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![helloiamvu](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/helloiamvu/32/481_2.png) [@helloiamvu](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/helloiamvu)\
**Post date:** [May 12, 2025, 9:19pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/26 "2025-05-12T21:19:36Z")

</div>

Jumping in here as a follow-up to @repe earlier response.

To clarify: Marinade was aware that some validators were underpaying after delegation due to how priority logic and rebalancing worked. This was a known inefficiency — not a critical bug — and one of several areas identified for improvement in the ongoing evolution of SAM.

At the time, the team prioritized other protocol-level work. Marinade operates with limited engineering capacity and focuses on system-level improvements rather than isolated quick fixes. Public communication was made to discourage this validator behavior, though it’s fair to say the message could have been more explicit.

A few important points:

- Marinade has never advertised inflated APY
- All APY reflects realized performance
- User funds have consistently remained fully secure and actively earning yield

The recently launched `BidTooLow` penalty now addresses this validator behavior directly at the protocol level. A broader update to unstake priority logic is also underway, with implementation planning already in motion.

The framing that Marinade knowingly allowed a bug to persist for 120 epochs isn’t accurate. This was a matter of prioritization. SAM continues to evolve as designed, with adjustments made based on observed validator behavior and protocol performance over time.

It’s true that a few validators have set their MEV commission to 100%, meaning stakers don’t currently share in those rewards. Marinade is actively working through rebalances to adjust delegation away from these validators. However, the immediate focus is on rotating out of validators with zero bond first, in line with the protocol’s Protected Staking Rewards design. That sequencing helps maintain efficient delegation management while upholding performance expectations. This isn’t just about maximizing rewards — it’s about operating a consistent and reliable delegation process.

Regarding validators with very low or near-zero bids still holding delegation: through active rebalancing and redelegation to other validators. However, Marinade also factors in reallocation cost and network conditions when shifting large volumes of stake. Moving another 1–2 million SOL all at once would be inefficient and could reduce net yield. Instead, the reallocation is being handled in a targeted and accelerated way, with active oversight to ensure meaningful progress.

Appreciate the continued engagement — and happy to provide more detail where useful.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Paws](https://forum.marinade.finance/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/p/dfb087/32.png) [@Paws](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Paws)\
**Post date:** [May 13, 2025, 2:27am UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/27 "2025-05-13T02:27:08Z")

</div>

> [@Shiroi](#):
>
> Additionally, it’s worth noting that **5 validators have set their MEV commission to 100%** , meaning that **stakers are not receiving any MEV income** from these validators. The total stake for these validators is **410,000 SOL**.

What exactly is the problem with a validator setting their MEV commission to 100%?

If a validator doesn’t run the Jito client, there wouldn’t be any MEV rewards to begin with. So choosing to run Jito and then keeping 100% of the MEV rewards shouldn’t be seen as an issue—it’s entirely within the validator’s discretion.

Of course, I agree that it’s inefficient and problematic if a validator with _both_ a low bid _and_ a low inherent APY continues to retain delegation. That much is clear.

However, Marinade’s auction is designed to delegate based on the _total APY_, which includes both the validator’s inherent APY and their bid. Even if a validator has a low inherent APY, as long as they make up for it with an adequate bid, it should not matter—and from a staker’s perspective, there’s no inherent reason why MEV rewards need to be part of the APY composition.

Let’s also remember that Marinade’s eligibility criteria are clearly defined:

- Validator is not blacklisted (e.g., running harmful mods, commission rugs)
- Validator runs a supported node version (within the specified semver bounds)
- Validator’s final inflation commission is ≤ 7% (with bids and MEV commission considered as offsets)
- Validator had \>80% uptime in each of the last 3 epochs (based on stake-weighted vote credits)

As long as these conditions are met, how a validator chooses to structure their commission—including MEV—is entirely up to them. There is no justification for condemning that choice.

The way you highlight “MEV 100%” suggests a negative bias against validators who choose to keep all of their MEV rewards. I would encourage you—just as you often urge others—to focus on the data and engage in calm, logically consistent analysis.

* * *

EDIT:

Just to reiterate: in the specific case you were discussing, I do understand the concern with a validator that sets MEV commission to 100%, has a low inherent APY, and also bids low—yet still retains delegation. That’s a valid issue to raise.

However, I must say I’m a bit disappointed that, despite frequently stating you’re not making ethical judgments and are simply presenting data, you consistently mix in moral arguments. Unless that approach changes, it’s difficult to fully engage on the level of purely rational, data-driven discussion you often advocate for.

I genuinely hope you’ll continue the conversation with a clear focus on logic and data, without letting emotions or implicit value judgments cloud the analysis.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 13, 2025, 1:08pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/28 "2025-05-13T13:08:23Z")

</div>

Good day.

There’s absolutely no issue with setting a **100% MEV commission** — technically, that’s your call. But let’s be honest: the way you’re phrasing your question feels a bit disingenuous.  
It seems like you already know the answer — but sure, let me walk through it anyway.

The `MIN_effective_BID` is defined as the **minimum bid required** from a validator **with 0% inflation commission and 0% MEV commission**.  
If you decide to set your MEV commission to **100%** , then you’re effectively extracting **the entire MEV revenue from stakers**.  
That’s fine — but in return, **you should be compensating Marinade with a higher bid** , which in turn helps **reimburse the stakers via auction mechanics**.

But when a validator sets **100% MEV commission and a bid of 0** — what we have is a validator who **pays nothing for the stake** , and at the same time, **steals the entire MEV upside from the staker**.

At that point, it’s no longer just about Marinade losing out on auction revenue — **the staker ends up holding the bag** , with an APY that approaches **baseline inflation** , i.e., what you’d get from staking to a vanilla non-Jito validator.  
So let’s not pretend this isn’t a problem — I trust we’ve clarified that now.

* * *

Now, regarding the terminology I’ve used to describe validators who exploit this behavior.  
You’re apparently more upset about **the words** than the **economic damage** behind them.

So here’s a genuine question:  
**What term would you prefer** to describe a validator who actively takes advantage of a protocol loophole to receive free stake and extract full MEV at the expense of the staker?

I’ve published the full methodology, the validator list, and detailed loss estimates.  
Instead of pointing out flaws in the data — or proposing a better model — you’re focusing on my choice of labels?

Seems a bit odd, no?

Still, I’m open to suggestions.  
If you’ve got a more “ethically neutral” term that doesn’t hurt anyone’s feelings, I’ll gladly adopt it going forward.  
But let’s please **shift the focus back to the numbers** , not the semantics.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![SouthCloud0703](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/southcloud0703/32/453_2.png) [@SouthCloud0703](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/SouthCloud0703)\
**Post date:** [May 14, 2025, 1:06pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/29 "2025-05-14T13:06:30Z")

</div>

> [@MIP.9 - Blocklisting malicious validators from Stake Auction Marketplace to combat sandwich attacks](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/mip-9-blocklisting-malicious-validators-from-stake-auction-marketplace-to-combat-sandwich-attacks/1716):
>
> Introduction Based on widespread community concerns and transparent research findings, this DAO proposal seeks to implement a blocklist mechanism within the Stake Auction Marketplace (SAM). Sandwich attacks—where validators manipulate transaction ordering to profit from front-running and back-running—have been widely recognized by the community as harmful practices that undermine fair trade execution and decentralization. Marinade is committed to fostering a staker-aligned, market-driven redistr…

I understood that validators conducting sandwich attacks were banned, but are they still around?  
However, I truly don’t understand how they are maintaining such high bids and still achieving an economically rational state.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 17, 2025, 11:28am UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/30 "2025-05-17T11:28:47Z")

</div>

**Keeping the community looped in, as always.**  
It’s been 5 days since the last status dump — back then we were at epoch 785, now we’re clocking in at 788. So, 3 epochs later… what’s the delta?

**MIN\_effective\_bid for 788 epoch = 0.0899**

Number of validators with `bidCpmpe` \< `MIN_effective_bid`: **85**  
That’s down by 7 nodes — used to be 92. Looks like some folks finally read the docs.

Total delegated SOL to these underbidders: **3,413,112.97 SOL**  
That’s a **+31% spike** (compared to 2,590,198 in epoch 785).  
And guess what? The system is **working as intended™**.

**The current lost profit of the pool for the 788th epoch is - 250 SOL**

Only **2 out of those 85 validators** triggered the new **BidTooLow** penalty.  
And… is anyone really surprised? Most of these validators have been hard-sticking to `bidCpmpe = 0` (or close enough), so the new penalty system is just background noise to them.

Scroll down for the table of validators who are riding with **1000+ SOL from Marinade**.

| voteAccount | marinadeActivatedStakeSol | bidCpmpe | Inflation Commission | MEV Commission | Stake Priority | Unstake Priority |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Cue647T8jgwpRSDUb8ttTYx7NiEfJCRZNiiw1qmchXsG | 334472,4254 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 273 | 128 |
| 4m1PbxzwLdUnEwog3T9UKxgjktgriHgE1CfAhMqDw7Xx | 309581,1751 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 273 | 129 |
| vskzrzSd6owQiNb2YA52ZM4YtRzmsSyp6dJbjx2zTVN | 260401,4938 | 0,082 | 0 | 0,1 | 144 | 37 |
| DPhzpiNGU9C6576uLsNSHmdi2AxwxpjMsRdh2iVC4TPh | 208750,3714 | 0,08 | 0 | 0,1 | 146 | 70 |
| ErJmwESSzVrDuDJcN5L47XnM84JWDwTi6bDMWkrXqHSV | 197364,8843 | 0 | 0,05 | 1 | 298 | 140 |
| 9f7dqiYNBZbgPesAnLeWnKCtxYHSfMg5x1EMZCJwVwG7 | 138898,6203 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0,1 | 240 | 97 |
| 4WGMxMKhjKz9TSmn6NA52AVipeE3zZNPBhQuBghZBvqU | 131670,5104 | 0 | 0,07 | 1 | 300 | 143 |
| Simpj3KyRQmpRkXuBvCQFS7DBBG6vqw93SkZb9UD1hp | 128309,5058 | 1,00E-07 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 271 | 125 |
| 9gANMngbGUmAaLXL1RC3JdiaLjRowJXNbzCTh53ht7mq | 114185,0991 | 0,08 | 0 | 0 | 137 | 65 |
| GMiBDMmwFRZfxVuHt3bXe6ZF7mGUBGWKXHLfY97NwQ72 | 108339,2121 | 0,007 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 259 | 114 |
| 21wUViiyG1g47VZ39ZZsSkFX9nu6bkyfy6jryHGD2TUB | 107158,9541 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0,1 | 240 | 98 |
| EARTHZeTM64X3UMYf5rcWonQkTCn3uifEwutBx6e656K | 82551,78148 | 0 | 0,07 | 0,1 | 281 | 136 |
| StepeLdhJ2znRjHcZdjwMWsC4nTRURNKQY8Nca82LJp | 81394,87546 | 0 | 0,07 | 1 | 300 | 142 |
| 5akpkYincAbsTBXVbf2GDCg4KatMnc8BKkXZCh7MWGPK | 79482,29161 | 8,00E-05 | 0 | 0,1 | 233 | 93 |
| 3teZKwABvB99bxZc5q8yVWJt5mbhxgUAx4teMdUbzgN4 | 77371,76732 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,0999 | 228 | 89 |
| 2w4dcnbJDcGrAh4CFAYYpAaEJiUB2q1rFMGByBuB5Cqz | 75954,35784 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,08 | 223 | 84 |
| HvuXZAhAqSekCFueQ92DqxhuFvdBRrWeyA6uea6ZaS8q | 74861,20702 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 229 | 90 |
| 2wUhcnViyzstvWmk7NAboKtjbFbqJPo4BvFBV37dacLc | 61036,37503 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 210 | 80 |
| 8StzUMT1Kq33EHPoFx9zYhfuvzAbiqeh5nE3DftLLDPG | 60103,69085 | 0,04 | 0 | 0 | 162 | 73 |
| ABs7XJAwHJpmBfC2y677bH5jzNtt5cAxXc14Q5bWgQRd | 59415,09976 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 253 | 110 |
| 3ZUQekqiZoybB57y49eqtvSaoonqDwuNbeqEGwN88JkQ | 54708,13471 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0 | 209 | 76 |
| Hx4UJCvf8amGeuW9fPFfTckRoznDHxPSYiU9HuUSZKLT | 52330,77599 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 273 | 132 |
| 8ztfVJM7Yf7CMXqTGMGBkXmTkGCiJTgVfh1CYDZZND5b | 51730,87296 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 273 | 133 |
| EJHf5N9is5spAF5Kz384tTvTV3CwTka6qzUoZrYm53SV | 49893,36157 | 1,00E-09 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 272 | 127 |
| 3tjGkvUsNEk8UBUQECCTpeAoo6NovHvEG44MZDPCcZko | 47526,53407 | 0,005 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 261 | 117 |
| 3CnKZPQn92W8WXG7KTVaFQRk8LJJ3KZbrVVF4ngUxqkg | 46178,63431 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 229 | 92 |
| Fbnesg4kSDDoFbjaSiDQJ3GXHHAnNb1CJCgLQp4dxj4C | 38228,98188 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 229 | 91 |
| ANRnEc3NFWyDFkJNHPnts9XAT1odt931qbgzMsSGdE1z | 35648,6937 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,05 | 248 | 109 |
| 8D8XL6ovqx15RKwC1XtFyTz6H8JYF2fUsxTnsY4b123P | 34857,93898 | 0,075 | 0 | 0 | 142 | 69 |
| DsT3eKbWAaX9wVZQYBsbkDwpFA9NTDtXfsYc9wXUEWpn | 34027,83092 | 8,00E-07 | 0 | 0,1 | 238 | 96 |
| BHuk6wv9pskvSuMxzAFksmFNxEWZDHDsYWSwvTKcCnhx | 30284,08386 | 0,004 | 0 | 0,07 | 213 | 82 |
| 76DafWkJ6pGK2hoD41HjrM4xTBhfKqrDYDazv13n5ir1 | 28188,80313 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 253 | 111 |
| HMLfMHdETcGSqPGAr38rSiwewsSZvLPMMPALc5pggtiW | 27348,78789 | 0,002 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 264 | 121 |
| Anv7J9kMdJWr1aU6rQvQyd24zBp5GscP8NeDpRqGKz8e | 23530,14604 | 8,00E-07 | 0,07 | 0,1 | 280 | 50 |
| 323d4ZiSqS1PwGwpJwD88jNPaGqkm7YYW2tJt2T8iFzo | 21666,60491 | 1,00E-05 | 0 | 0,1 | 236 | 95 |
| 8HKqT579dAjdTy86zKUs8kAaGDHXY11wDC3ohGCkLSQH | 16840,81923 | 0,0085 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 254 | 113 |
| sBcuGeMJCRkdtMNgskLTX7MePb4CzCqZuyMKDrcPP8v | 16724,01134 | 8,00E-07 | 0,07 | 0 | 274 | 51 |
| 8FPz3JG4E3HVXxGbPZVibarva4AGXSZWx3qKLUS5uFtN | 12372,80302 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 292 | 139 |
| CSWfwhactcdyK2YcRmk3Hx1AZzNKDFnCecwiYsJDkuSm | 12133,0349 | 0,011 | 0,05 | 0,05 | 247 | 108 |
| GA2t11gJcmuZ4y7pShTzgYDkxVaJaVQJqkVUqojhPPsT | 10356,86811 | 4,00E-09 | 0,04 | 0,1 | 262 | 118 |
| GeYn4XjKycYJ6NqTFb94sYowMrtmKfHBcorE6SGAomQN | 10335,13467 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0 | 244 | 105 |
| DTwEEF6VSrmTBYkDcj3BKAc52qhvP8CEQUEAMMT1cG3 | 10058,52348 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 241 | 103 |
| GB44NXtM7zGm6QnzQjzHZcRKSswkJbox8aJsKiXGbFJr | 9328,412354 | 0 | 0,01 | 0,08 | 245 | 106 |
| 8DHFGo3fDB8GudbNLZEyExLzXQPwvY4twybPbxwDnffx | 8117,594564 | 0,085 | 0 | 0,1 | 141 | 68 |
| juicQdAnksqZ5Yb8NQwCLjLWhykvXGktxnQCDvMe6Nx | 6994,420739 | 0 | 0,04 | 0,08 | 260 | 115 |
| H7fXvnLCKtZqJBTipxeseabGfAZUdHJ9XuP6hCKrbvUb | 6019,449886 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 227 | 88 |
| EARNynHRWg6GfyJCmrrizcZxARB3HVzcaasvNa8kBS72 | 3741,042078 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 241 | 99 |
| WENuuMXGi8adKogNbQj33Vxgia9oA2erkWAPF4szWN1 | 3515,782977 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 210 | 81 |
| BeSov1og3sEYyH9JY3ap7QcQDvVX8f4sugfNPf9YLkcV | 3151,755416 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 241 | 100 |
| Hoo2PaowEdA1owJ4t6uJFGdSbgyWV5qGYRtTVChHgw3x | 2070,323293 | 0,080000222 | 0 | 0,0001 | 138 | 66 |
| FyrSH4VeQidMVPQ9AE2szAbP5xBZBprRG3z1QMMLNi5X | 1603,058266 | 1,00E-06 | 0 | 0,1 | 237 | 47 |
| vahVByZszdHguLa7U7GLz8UdUFN85mcwdkefiqVjtGt | 1579,182102 | 0 | 0 | 0,099 | 235 | 94 |
| FnAPJkzf19s87sm24Qhv6bHZMZvZ43gjNUBRgjwXpD4v | 1539,598457 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 227 | 86 |
| ErvMUdtMC7AX55zKdYSyy4DnWNCrTsWn5GwprSG7ocnx | 1311,160141 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 273 | 135 |
| CogentC52e7kktFfWHwsqSmr8LiS1yAtfqhHcftCPcBJ | 1143,06457 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 210 | 78 |
| eondcw2upjH14EuvBzmn6HfGEGo8t9hG9JbXtPj6cym | 1108,967145 | 0,01 | 0 | 0,1 | 203 | 44 |

**To the Marinade team:**  
When are you finally going to fix your Stake Priority and Unstake Priority ranking logic for validators?  
Isn’t it obvious by now that **this is your core issue**?

No amount of patchwork elsewhere will matter until this part of the system stops acting like a random number generator.

To be continued…

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 17, 2025, 11:29am UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/31 "2025-05-17T11:29:46Z")

</div>

Good day. Please take a look at my last post in this thread…

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 17, 2025, 11:32am UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/32 "2025-05-17T11:32:52Z")

</div>

This was in February, and no action has been taken yet?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 22, 2025, 9:21pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/33 "2025-05-22T21:21:50Z")

</div>

**We continue to maintain transparency and keep the community informed about the ongoing inefficiencies in Marinade’s ranking mechanism — an issue that, regrettably, remains unresolved.**

It has now been 3 epochs since our last report (epoch 788); this update covers **epoch 791**.

**Current `MIN_effective_bid`: 0.09246**

- **Number of validators with `bidCpmpe` below this threshold: 80**  
Down from 85 in the previous epoch. It appears some participants have started paying attention — albeit slowly.
- **Total SOL delegated to these validators: 2,576,289 SOL**  
Previously: 3,413,112.97 SOL in epoch 788. That’s a **24.51% reduction** in undercompensated stake — a welcome correction, all things considered.
- **The current lost profit of the pool for epoch 791 is 231 SOL.**
- **Only one validator in this category received a `BidTooLow` penalty in this epoch:**  
`3pBPy27F1Wz3iVydZnGkdvefStrFm8UMCDakYZii8AUZ`  
This validator has been excluded from the list below. All others included have **not** received any penalties.

| voteAccount | marinadeActivatedStakeSol | bidCpmpe | Inflation Commission | MEV Commission | Stake Priority | Unstake Priority |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Cue647T8jgwpRSDUb8ttTYx7NiEfJCRZNiiw1qmchXsG | 334116,3528 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 265 | 106 |
| ErJmwESSzVrDuDJcN5L47XnM84JWDwTi6bDMWkrXqHSV | 197577,8264 | 0 | 0,05 | 1 | 290 | 118 |
| 4m1PbxzwLdUnEwog3T9UKxgjktgriHgE1CfAhMqDw7Xx | 157035,8038 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 265 | 107 |
| 9f7dqiYNBZbgPesAnLeWnKCtxYHSfMg5x1EMZCJwVwG7 | 139011,6338 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0,1 | 234 | 76 |
| 4WGMxMKhjKz9TSmn6NA52AVipeE3zZNPBhQuBghZBvqU | 131809,5912 | 0 | 0,07 | 1 | 292 | 121 |
| Simpj3KyRQmpRkXuBvCQFS7DBBG6vqw93SkZb9UD1hp | 128249,1765 | 1,00E-07 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 263 | 104 |
| GMiBDMmwFRZfxVuHt3bXe6ZF7mGUBGWKXHLfY97NwQ72 | 107945,3794 | 0,007 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 252 | 93 |
| 21wUViiyG1g47VZ39ZZsSkFX9nu6bkyfy6jryHGD2TUB | 107280,7471 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0,1 | 234 | 77 |
| EARTHZeTM64X3UMYf5rcWonQkTCn3uifEwutBx6e656K | 82638,96265 | 0 | 0,07 | 0,1 | 273 | 114 |
| StepeLdhJ2znRjHcZdjwMWsC4nTRURNKQY8Nca82LJp | 81480,80582 | 0 | 0,07 | 1 | 292 | 120 |
| 5akpkYincAbsTBXVbf2GDCg4KatMnc8BKkXZCh7MWGPK | 79542,59847 | 8,00E-05 | 0 | 0,1 | 228 | 0 |
| 3teZKwABvB99bxZc5q8yVWJt5mbhxgUAx4teMdUbzgN4 | 77459,70459 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,0999 | 223 | 70 |
| 2w4dcnbJDcGrAh4CFAYYpAaEJiUB2q1rFMGByBuB5Cqz | 76040,68458 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,08 | 218 | 65 |
| HvuXZAhAqSekCFueQ92DqxhuFvdBRrWeyA6uea6ZaS8q | 74946,29103 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 224 | 71 |
| 2wUhcnViyzstvWmk7NAboKtjbFbqJPo4BvFBV37dacLc | 60646,54263 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 205 | 60 |
| ABs7XJAwHJpmBfC2y677bH5jzNtt5cAxXc14Q5bWgQRd | 59206,28294 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 246 | 88 |
| 3ZUQekqiZoybB57y49eqtvSaoonqDwuNbeqEGwN88JkQ | 53171,52364 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0 | 204 | 56 |
| Hx4UJCvf8amGeuW9fPFfTckRoznDHxPSYiU9HuUSZKLT | 52059,12527 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 265 | 110 |
| 8ztfVJM7Yf7CMXqTGMGBkXmTkGCiJTgVfh1CYDZZND5b | 51309,3643 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 265 | 111 |
| EJHf5N9is5spAF5Kz384tTvTV3CwTka6qzUoZrYm53SV | 49130,35677 | 1,00E-09 | 0,05 | 0 | 250 | 92 |
| 3tjGkvUsNEk8UBUQECCTpeAoo6NovHvEG44MZDPCcZko | 47277,12558 | 0,005 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 254 | 96 |
| 3CnKZPQn92W8WXG7KTVaFQRk8LJJ3KZbrVVF4ngUxqkg | 46231,10921 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 224 | 73 |
| Fbnesg4kSDDoFbjaSiDQJ3GXHHAnNb1CJCgLQp4dxj4C | 38268,10412 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 224 | 72 |
| ANRnEc3NFWyDFkJNHPnts9XAT1odt931qbgzMsSGdE1z | 35574,89721 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,05 | 241 | 87 |
| 8D8XL6ovqx15RKwC1XtFyTz6H8JYF2fUsxTnsY4b123P | 34882,61515 | 0,075 | 0 | 0 | 137 | 49 |
| BHuk6wv9pskvSuMxzAFksmFNxEWZDHDsYWSwvTKcCnhx | 30318,50295 | 0,004 | 0 | 0,07 | 208 | 62 |
| 76DafWkJ6pGK2hoD41HjrM4xTBhfKqrDYDazv13n5ir1 | 27985,03971 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 246 | 89 |
| HMLfMHdETcGSqPGAr38rSiwewsSZvLPMMPALc5pggtiW | 27146,52792 | 0,002 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 257 | 100 |
| Anv7J9kMdJWr1aU6rQvQyd24zBp5GscP8NeDpRqGKz8e | 23555,01402 | 8,00E-07 | 0,07 | 0,1 | 272 | 30 |
| 323d4ZiSqS1PwGwpJwD88jNPaGqkm7YYW2tJt2T8iFzo | 21688,61709 | 1,00E-05 | 0 | 0,1 | 230 | 75 |
| sBcuGeMJCRkdtMNgskLTX7MePb4CzCqZuyMKDrcPP8v | 16741,68613 | 8,00E-07 | 0,07 | 0 | 266 | 32 |
| 8HKqT579dAjdTy86zKUs8kAaGDHXY11wDC3ohGCkLSQH | 16739,35973 | 0,0085 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 247 | 91 |
| 8FPz3JG4E3HVXxGbPZVibarva4AGXSZWx3qKLUS5uFtN | 12386,86518 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 235 | 82 |
| CSWfwhactcdyK2YcRmk3Hx1AZzNKDFnCecwiYsJDkuSm | 12050,15362 | 0,011 | 0,05 | 0,05 | 240 | 86 |
| GA2t11gJcmuZ4y7pShTzgYDkxVaJaVQJqkVUqojhPPsT | 10367,11158 | 4,00E-09 | 0,04 | 0,1 | 255 | 97 |
| DTwEEF6VSrmTBYkDcj3BKAc52qhvP8CEQUEAMMT1cG3 | 10069,92605 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 235 | 81 |
| GB44NXtM7zGm6QnzQjzHZcRKSswkJbox8aJsKiXGbFJr | 9338,901903 | 0 | 0,01 | 0,08 | 238 | 84 |
| 3xjfK9C9YNcta8MvK1US4sQ3bc6DEjoJoR3qLExGf9xE | 8995,541523 | 0,011 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 245 | 28 |
| 8DHFGo3fDB8GudbNLZEyExLzXQPwvY4twybPbxwDnffx | 8125,814569 | 0,085 | 0 | 0,1 | 135 | 48 |
| juicQdAnksqZ5Yb8NQwCLjLWhykvXGktxnQCDvMe6Nx | 7002,047127 | 0 | 0,04 | 0,08 | 253 | 94 |
| H7fXvnLCKtZqJBTipxeseabGfAZUdHJ9XuP6hCKrbvUb | 6026,283343 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 222 | 69 |
| EARNynHRWg6GfyJCmrrizcZxARB3HVzcaasvNa8kBS72 | 3745,291217 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 235 | 78 |
| WENuuMXGi8adKogNbQj33Vxgia9oA2erkWAPF4szWN1 | 3519,774851 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 205 | 61 |
| BeSov1og3sEYyH9JY3ap7QcQDvVX8f4sugfNPf9YLkcV | 3155,334593 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 235 | 79 |
| CogentC52e7kktFfWHwsqSmr8LiS1yAtfqhHcftCPcBJ | 1794,261648 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 205 | 58 |
| vahVByZszdHguLa7U7GLz8UdUFN85mcwdkefiqVjtGt | 1580,976227 | 0 | 0 | 0,099 | 229 | 74 |
| FnAPJkzf19s87sm24Qhv6bHZMZvZ43gjNUBRgjwXpD4v | 1541,348301 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 222 | 67 |
| HLXktVmNFeELB5uL5nrpP4WL7jyi3TMyekxASVjDhZ1t | 1518,734396 | 0,09 | 0 | 0 | 129 | 46 |
| ErvMUdtMC7AX55zKdYSyy4DnWNCrTsWn5GwprSG7ocnx | 1312,574841 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 265 | 113 |

**As we can see from the table, validators holding 100k–300k SOL in stake with a bid of 0 have an Unstake Priority of around 100.**  
In practice, this means that — under the current auction logic — bots will **never** reach them to reallocate stake.  
Their position effectively removes them from the competition, yet their stake remains untouched.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![SouthCloud0703](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/southcloud0703/32/453_2.png) [@SouthCloud0703](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/SouthCloud0703)\
**Post date:** [May 23, 2025, 2:16pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/34 "2025-05-23T14:16:43Z")

</div>

I believe that the emergency unstaking of these validators has progressed in the most recent epoch, leading to improved health of the system. Sooner or later, I think the remaining delegations will also be unstaked in order.

I think the community should focus on the more serious Marinade Sandwicher problem rather than this issue. Currently, it is undoubtedly serving as a breeding ground for Marinade’s Sandwichers and harming the Solana network experience, which should be improved immediately. [https://x.com/chrischang43/status/1925629929900687609](https://x.com/chrischang43/status/1925629929900687609)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [May 30, 2025, 12:09pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/35 "2025-05-30T12:09:03Z")

</div>

**Epoch 794 Report**

Three epochs have passed since the last report (previously epoch 791).

**MIN\_effective\_bid = 0.07492 SOL**

- **Number of validators with `bidCpmpe` below MIN\_effective\_bid:** 59  
This is a decrease of 21 from the previous count of 80.
- **Total SOL delegated to these validators:** 1,541,261 SOL  
(Previously 2,576,289 SOL — a nearly 40% reduction in unpaid stake. Excellent progress!)
- **Two validators** with a bid below the MIN\_effective\_bid in this epoch received a `BidTooLow` penalty:
  - `6rC1zg98a89eQurdnvXz6uJ3zZZa2f683WwCDB41Us8w`
  - `8F4e1nbeC6hn9jkojtboERZGaafxUUtsqUy3MKJLohkh`  
(This validator has been excluded from the list below. The list only includes validators with **no penalties**.)

- **Total penalties paid by these two validators:** 73.46 SOL
- **Missed revenue for Marinade:** 111 SOL
- **Net missed revenue after penalties:** 37.54 SOL  
The core team has nearly resolved the issue.

Below is a table listing validators with over **1,000 SOL** delegated from Marinade.

| Vote Account | Marinade Stake (SOL) | Bid CPMPE | Inflation Commission | MEV Commission | Stake Priority | Unstake Priority |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Cue647T8jgwpRSDUb8ttTYx7NiEfJCRZNiiw1qmchXsG | 183707,8779 | 0,001 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 250 | 118 |
| 4m1PbxzwLdUnEwog3T9UKxgjktgriHgE1CfAhMqDw7Xx | 157203,9968 | 0,001 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 250 | 119 |
| 9f7dqiYNBZbgPesAnLeWnKCtxYHSfMg5x1EMZCJwVwG7 | 138709,2406 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0,1 | 223 | 93 |
| 21wUViiyG1g47VZ39ZZsSkFX9nu6bkyfy6jryHGD2TUB | 107401,7604 | 1,00E-09 | 0 | 0,1 | 223 | 94 |
| GMiBDMmwFRZfxVuHt3bXe6ZF7mGUBGWKXHLfY97NwQ72 | 99779,53839 | 0,007 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 242 | 109 |
| 5akpkYincAbsTBXVbf2GDCg4KatMnc8BKkXZCh7MWGPK | 77639,80223 | 8,00E-05 | 0 | 0,1 | 217 | 90 |
| 3teZKwABvB99bxZc5q8yVWJt5mbhxgUAx4teMdUbzgN4 | 77547,08012 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,0999 | 212 | 86 |
| 2w4dcnbJDcGrAh4CFAYYpAaEJiUB2q1rFMGByBuB5Cqz | 76126,45968 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,08 | 207 | 81 |
| HvuXZAhAqSekCFueQ92DqxhuFvdBRrWeyA6uea6ZaS8q | 75030,83125 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 213 | 87 |
| ABs7XJAwHJpmBfC2y677bH5jzNtt5cAxXc14Q5bWgQRd | 57199,75578 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 236 | 105 |
| 3CnKZPQn92W8WXG7KTVaFQRk8LJJ3KZbrVVF4ngUxqkg | 46283,25823 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 213 | 89 |
| 3ZUQekqiZoybB57y49eqtvSaoonqDwuNbeqEGwN88JkQ | 45369,13897 | 0,002 | 0 | 0 | 191 | 72 |
| EJHf5N9is5spAF5Kz384tTvTV3CwTka6qzUoZrYm53SV | 43461,27171 | 0,010000001 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 235 | 104 |
| Fbnesg4kSDDoFbjaSiDQJ3GXHHAnNb1CJCgLQp4dxj4C | 38311,26991 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 213 | 88 |
| ANRnEc3NFWyDFkJNHPnts9XAT1odt931qbgzMsSGdE1z | 34641,13334 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,05 | 230 | 103 |
| BHuk6wv9pskvSuMxzAFksmFNxEWZDHDsYWSwvTKcCnhx | 29605,61302 | 0,004 | 0 | 0,07 | 197 | 78 |
| 76DafWkJ6pGK2hoD41HjrM4xTBhfKqrDYDazv13n5ir1 | 26022,55933 | 0,01 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 236 | 106 |
| 323d4ZiSqS1PwGwpJwD88jNPaGqkm7YYW2tJt2T8iFzo | 21578,58392 | 1,00E-05 | 0 | 0,1 | 219 | 92 |
| 8HKqT579dAjdTy86zKUs8kAaGDHXY11wDC3ohGCkLSQH | 15469,64918 | 0,0085 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 237 | 107 |
| CSWfwhactcdyK2YcRmk3Hx1AZzNKDFnCecwiYsJDkuSm | 11234,94186 | 0,011 | 0,05 | 0,05 | 229 | 102 |
| GA2t11gJcmuZ4y7pShTzgYDkxVaJaVQJqkVUqojhPPsT | 10315,49874 | 4,00E-09 | 0,04 | 0,1 | 245 | 113 |
| DTwEEF6VSrmTBYkDcj3BKAc52qhvP8CEQUEAMMT1cG3 | 10081,27285 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 224 | 98 |
| GB44NXtM7zGm6QnzQjzHZcRKSswkJbox8aJsKiXGbFJr | 9349,326091 | 0 | 0,01 | 0,08 | 227 | 100 |
| 3tjGkvUsNEk8UBUQECCTpeAoo6NovHvEG44MZDPCcZko | 8163,650764 | 0,005 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 244 | 112 |
| juicQdAnksqZ5Yb8NQwCLjLWhykvXGktxnQCDvMe6Nx | 7027,176591 | 0 | 0,04 | 0,08 | 243 | 110 |
| H7fXvnLCKtZqJBTipxeseabGfAZUdHJ9XuP6hCKrbvUb | 6033,074161 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 211 | 85 |
| EARNynHRWg6GfyJCmrrizcZxARB3HVzcaasvNa8kBS72 | 3749,514019 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 224 | 95 |
| WENuuMXGi8adKogNbQj33Vxgia9oA2erkWAPF4szWN1 | 3523,74207 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 194 | 77 |
| BeSov1og3sEYyH9JY3ap7QcQDvVX8f4sugfNPf9YLkcV | 3158,891728 | 0 | 0 | 0,1 | 224 | 96 |
| CogentC52e7kktFfWHwsqSmr8LiS1yAtfqhHcftCPcBJ | 1820,97979 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 194 | 75 |
| vahVByZszdHguLa7U7GLz8UdUFN85mcwdkefiqVjtGt | 1582,759567 | 0 | 0 | 0,099 | 218 | 91 |
| FnAPJkzf19s87sm24Qhv6bHZMZvZ43gjNUBRgjwXpD4v | 1543,086958 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 211 | 83 |
| ErvMUdtMC7AX55zKdYSyy4DnWNCrTsWn5GwprSG7ocnx | 1313,980672 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 256 | 124 |

But as we can see from the table, the issue with the incorrect calculation of **Unstake Priority** still hasn’t been resolved. ☹

Stay tuned for further updates…

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [June 8, 2025, 9:45pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/36 "2025-06-08T21:45:09Z")

</div>

**Good day, dear friends. We continue our analysis of the Marinade auction performance.**

**Epoch Report: 799**  
(Five epochs have passed since the last update — the previous one covered epoch 794)

**MIN\_effective\_bid = 0.0429 SOL**

**Number of validators with `bidCpmpe` below `MIN_effective_bid`: 24**  
Down by 35 since the last report (which listed 59 validators). Great job!

**Total SOL delegated to these validators: 534,500 SOL**  
Previously: 1,541,261 SOL — an almost 3x reduction. Excellent progress!

**Estimated missed revenue for Marinade this epoch: ~20 SOL**

| | Vote Account | Marinade Stake (SOL) | Bid CPMPE | Inflation Commission | MEV Commission | Stake Priority | Unstake Priority |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Cue647T8jgwpRSDUb8ttTYx7NiEfJCRZNiiw1qmchXsG | 184035,3496 | 0,001 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 249 | 94 |
| 2 | 5akpkYincAbsTBXVbf2GDCg4KatMnc8BKkXZCh7MWGPK | 77781,25356 | 0,031 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 181 | 79 |
| 3 | 3teZKwABvB99bxZc5q8yVWJt5mbhxgUAx4teMdUbzgN4 | 77692,73493 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,0999 | 211 | 87 |
| 4 | 2w4dcnbJDcGrAh4CFAYYpAaEJiUB2q1rFMGByBuB5Cqz | 76269,44674 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,08 | 208 | 11 |
| 5 | 3CnKZPQn92W8WXG7KTVaFQRk8LJJ3KZbrVVF4ngUxqkg | 46370,19109 | 0,001 | 0 | 0,1 | 212 | 88 |
| 6 | 8NQEDxYxwUEPQk1yKFJEGHvYj22Je5xUQWLPkHfKkwrD | 28493,88982 | 0 | 0,05 | 0,1 | 257 | 18 |
| 7 | BHuk6wv9pskvSuMxzAFksmFNxEWZDHDsYWSwvTKcCnhx | 28352,52548 | 0,004 | 0 | 0,07 | 197 | 80 |
| 8 | H7fXvnLCKtZqJBTipxeseabGfAZUdHJ9XuP6hCKrbvUb | 6044,389978 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 214 | 92 |
| 9 | WENuuMXGi8adKogNbQj33Vxgia9oA2erkWAPF4szWN1 | 3530,353231 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 201 | 84 |
| 10 | StepeLdhJ2znRjHcZdjwMWsC4nTRURNKQY8Nca82LJp | 1691,710829 | 0 | 0,07 | 1 | 277 | 96 |
| 11 | vahVByZszdHguLa7U7GLz8UdUFN85mcwdkefiqVjtGt | 1585,731549 | 0 | 0 | 0,099 | 220 | 93 |
| 12 | FnAPJkzf19s87sm24Qhv6bHZMZvZ43gjNUBRgjwXpD4v | 1545,985305 | 0 | 0 | 0,08 | 214 | 90 |
| 13 | 644K33yWfSzc32VvY5fRUfUqphw8LTaLQntCkyEpJ8h7 | 1060,43966 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 201 | 83 |

**P.S.** As usual, the table only includes validators with more than 1,000 SOL staked by Marinade.

We’re almost at the point where Marinade can fully offset its historical losses through penalty collections alone. However, as the table clearly shows — the issue with **Unstake Priority** still remains unresolved.

Let’s keep watching. Until next time!

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/user_avatar/forum.marinade.finance/shiroi/32/451_2.png) [@Shiroi](https://forum.marinade.finance/u/Shiroi)\
**Post date:** [June 17, 2025, 4:35pm UTC](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853/37 "2025-06-17T16:35:29Z")

</div>

**Hello everyone** ,

As of epoch 804, we’re pleased to report that the Marinade team appears to have successfully addressed the issue of “free stake” allocation.  
**Now, every honest validator has a fair shot at the auction — and that’s great to see.**

We truly appreciate the attention given to this matter. Naturally, we would have welcomed more timely feedback from the team, but it is what it is. We’ll continue monitoring the auction closely, and should we discover any new loopholes, we’ll be sure to report them.

**Best regards,**  
**Shiroi team**

P.S. This thread can be closed.

[Previous page](https://forum.marinade.finance/t/incident-report-37-000-sol-in-losses-a-call-for-investigation-and-action/1853.md?page=1)
